Earlier today, Ziff Davis Publishing sold 1up Network to UGO Entertainment, and closed the print magazine "Electronic Gaming Monthly". Over 30 editors, video game reviewers and others lost their jobs, while holding the highest standard of presumably unbiased, ethical video game reviewing and news reporting.
Let me empathize: EGM will be missed.
Normally, this would be considered, and has almost immediately been considered, the death of print media for video games. I beg to differ in a lot of ways. I love the print media, and I have bought many EGM issues off the newsstand. (I also used to subscribe to Racer Magazine, for my racing news, but found that it was easier just to get the issues I wanted, rather than the biased crap I was regularly reading...) EGM started really dying when Dan "Shoe" Hsu left the magazine. I'll talk about that later... no wait, I'll discuss it now.
Editorial integrity in the video game market is ridiculous. It's utmost impossible to maintain, unless you have a sound mind of journalism. Seeking the truth is what journalism is all about. Dan Hsu did just that, and still does for his own site I'm sure, Sorethumbsblog.com. Dan has always questioned other magazines and their integrity over the advertising money they receive from publishers. For realistic purposes, no amount of money should change how terrible your game is, as if it does, that's corruption of journalist integrity. Calling out other print magazines for this is potentially hearsay, though, but having the balls to talk about it is something else. Later in his career, Shoe called out Peter Moore, while the 360 was "winning the war" so to speak, on the hardware issues that Microsoft's console still has today.
I'm not saying that editors have balls any more, but what I'm saying is if I was a publisher, I'd want this guy on my print mag or website. He asks the questions that the people want asked. He's like the Larry King of video game journalism (maybe that's a bad reference). When he left EGM, that dealt a huge blow to the popularity of the magazine as a whole, and turned the empathesis away from the print magazine itself, and more towards online journalism and blogging, much like the battle between the entertainment networks are having right now for your bandwidth.
Personally, I kept reading (and buying!) EGM after Shoe's departure. The magazine went to letter scores (which I hate with a passion, because I hate review scores, and totally prefer a buy-rent-garbage structure) and flourished with awesome developer interviews and interesting event coverage. James Mielke had, forgive the pun, a big Shoe to fill. Now that I think of puns, he also had big pants to fill. During the Gamespot-Kane and Lynch incident, which led to the wrongful firing of Jeff Gerstmann, EGM seemed to be in open arms of anyone willing to leave Gamespot for EGM. That was all Shoe's doing, praising good journalism in the wake of bad corporate decisions. It seems that EGM was doomed from that point going forward, when the economy began to worsen. (It actually did, in December 2007, when the recession truly began. Shoe left in April '08.)
Perhaps I'm just a really casual gamer when it comes to certain things, but when it comes to print mags, it's all I've really truly come to trust for my news. The internet just doesn't make it the same, but it's mostly opinionated. I'll miss EGM for the good times, for the Halo stuff, for the epic lulz near the back of every issue, and the letters to the editors that make for very entertaining poking and chiding at some silly readers.
So, without Ziff Davis getting my money any more, there's still Future and IDG, right?

Let's see here, we've got... OXM and Nintendo Power! Oh... and alright! GamePro! Sweet! We'll have to move the EGM issues into a safe place, once I finish scouring that December issue for Watchmen details, even though that movie isn't coming out....
I digress. Rest in Peace, Electronic Gaming Monthly. Good luck to those who lost their jobs, I hope you find something a hell of a lot more stable... just not with Ziff Davis.
- Ponza
P.S.: I'm sure SoreThumbsBlog will get bigger shortly.
